I tend not to comment on YouTube or any martial arts sites now. In the past, when I have, a reply has come from someone who casts doubt on my experience in Wing Chun, though they helpfully go on to show that it is they who know nothing of Wing Chun.
It's something I have been contemplating recently. Using the principle that the most effective weapon is that which remains concealed until needed, I'm actually happy when my Wing Chun experience is doubted. Furthermore, those who feel free to comment on Wing Chun, having only read briefly about the art or watched videos online, are doing the art a service indirectly: those who are foolish enough to take their word will never understand Wing Chun. Here is a good example of what I am talking about...
"Chi Sau is one of the very few ways to beat an opponent that is faster
than you besides blind luck. Just because you dont know how to slow your
opponents down using it doesnt mean its wrong. Someone who doesnt
believe in touch sensitivity (which is much faster and accurate than
eye) reaction probably doesn't know what it is even if they claim to be
First of all, it contains the loaded "just because you don't know" and "claim to be a student", which hint at the work of an internet troll trying to provoke a reaction - an evaluation given further credence by the fact that I said nothing about "touch sensitivity" in the comment which prompted the reaction. What he is referring to is the contact reflex, a term with which he would be familiar, if he were a student of Wing Chun.
It starts badly and continues from there, really. Chi Sau is not a way to beat an opponent that is faster than you. Actually, you will never directly use Chi Sau in a combat situation: it is simply a way of training responses which have been developed using the aforementioned contact reflex. Reaction times amongst humans also vary little so, if you are truly faced with someone who is faster than you are, they are superhuman and you should have run away while you had the chance.
I don't know how to slow down an opponent using Chi Sau? I hold my hands up on this one. If anyone can show me a clip of someone being slowed down by Chi Sau, I will say that some supernatural power is at work. Again, Chi Sau is not fighting: it trains responses through the use of developing a contact reflex. The only sure way to slow down an opponent, apart from compliant training partners in a martial arts class, is to hit them repeatedly in order to effect functional impairment. My own take on this is that a responsible human being will use only the force that is necessary.
"Someone who doesn't believe in touch sensitivity"? It's the wrong terminology. If I didn't believe in the sensitivity of my touch, I would constantly be knocking things over or dropping them. What he means is the contact reflex, which is so fundamental to Wing Chun that it would be lunacy to train Wing Chun if I really did not believe in it. It is faster and more accurate than the eye? No, it isn't. We react more slowly to what we see. If our hand was on fire, it would take us a while to connect the sight of our hand on fire to the concept of our hand being on fire, whereas our brain is wired to recognise pain instantly. The eye is not slower, but our reaction to what we see is slower than our reaction to what we feel.
As for me "claiming" to be a student of Wing Chun, there is no effective way to prove my experience as a student over the internet. Given all the problems with my accuser's comment, however, I would venture that he has never taken part in a genuine Wing Chun class or, if he has, clearly it has not been understood by him or explained in a way he understands. To think that I am wrong about his lack of experience, even for one moment, is truly horrifying. The reply came a year after my original comment, so was rendered unnecessary by the passing of time, and also shows a lack of respect that is truly unwelcome within the martial arts community (but is disappointingly common on YouTube).
The best comment I ever saw on a YouTube video stated that some people on YouTube believe themselves to be an expert in every martial art on the planet. I can't remember who originally made that comment, but full credit to them. The teenage boys, hyped up from watching UFC in their bedrooms or on their phones, usually lack the courage to actually attend a martial arts class, so insulting genuine martial artists from a safe distance passes for courage in their minds.
So, if I am being judged against the Wing Chun that these people know, I am happy to say that I know nothing of it.